On Monday (Dec. 14), Sports Illustrated announced their 2015 "Sportsperson of the Year" and the crown was given to none other than the tennis superstar herself, Serena Williams. While many believe she's deserving of the title, other fans of the publication were quite angry with their choice. Sports Illustrated held a reader's poll to see who fans wanted to carry the honor. A horse named American Pharaoh won by a landslide and now readers are pissed the animal didn't make it on the cover.
The 34-year-old was acknowledged for her moves both on and off the field. The 2015 "Sportsperson of the Year" title was not opinion based, but chosen based off her lengthy and enviable tennis career. Sports Illustrated highlighted several reasons why they believed Williams was a suitable pick for the annual honor.
Despite battling a vomit-enducing cold, bruised bones in her knees, and a sprained elbow, Williams dominated in 2015. She won 53 out of the 56 tennis matches she participated in this year (53-3 record), including three of the four Grand Slam events, and has held the no. 1 ranking for the past three years, according to the Womens Tennis Association (WTA).
A photo posted by Sports Illustrated (@sportsillustrated) on Dec 14, 2015 at 7:04am PST
The 21 Grand Slam singles title holder, who's pictured sitting upon her throne on the cover, was also recognized for the strides she's made for both women and African-Americans in sports. In November while dining out with a friend in San Francisco, Williams stopped a thief from running away with her cell phone.
She took to her personal social media accounts to detail her story and used it as an opportunity to empower girls and women, telling them to channel their inner Super Woman and stand up for themselves at all times.
So why were some people so outraged with the magazine's choice? On Nov. 11, Sports Illustrated opened an online reader's poll to give fans a chance to have a say in the voting process. Although the site clearly stated the Sports Illustrated editors will choose the official "Sportsperson of the Year" winner, fans still felt like their votes were ignored.
The contenders included 18-year-old gymnast Simone Bliss, track & field runner Earth Usain Bolt, basketball player Steph Curry, football player Thomas Davis, tennis player Novak Djokovic, soccer player Carli Lloyd, soccer player Lionel Messi, three-year-old horse American Pharaoh, UFC fighter Ronda Rousey, baseball team Kansas City Royals, 22-year-old golfer Jordan Spieth, and Williams.
American Pharaoh, who won with 47 percent of the votes, is a young colt that broke a 37-year Triple Crown drought by becoming the 12th winner in history to earn the title. Fans voiced their "disappointment" and anger towards the magazine for choosing Williams. Some people used the vote to discredit the tennis player's career.
"SI states that the sportsperson of the year award goes to 'the athlete or team whose performance that year embodies the spirit of sportsmanship and achievement.' That puts American Pharaoh at a clear disadvantage since horses can't really display sportsmanship."
Check out some of the comments below, including some Twitter users poking fun at those getting so worked up about a horse getting "snubbed" for the award:
They can just tell American Pharaoh that he won. He's a horse, he won't know the difference
— Jake Rapoport (@steaker) December 14, 2015
Very disappointed to see Sport's Illustrated editors ignored the fans vote, and chose Serena Williams over American Pharaoh - Article coming — Brian Zipse (@Zipseatthetrack) December 14, 2015
I love how you give it to someone who "almost" won a grand slam when you could've given it up to an athlete who actually did. @SInow
— Juanita Webb (@NitaMarie65) December 14, 2015
(2/2) disappointed that #AmericanPharoah the only nominee to actually win a #GRANDSLAM didn't get it. Why promote online poll? @SInow — Ashley Zayat (@AshleyZayat8) December 14, 2015
@GPatty_ @SInow Yup: She competed all year and lost exactly 3 matches. The horse competed 8 times and lost 1. 53–3 > 7-1.
— Ken Childs (@TheKenChilds) December 14, 2015
Total BS @SInow @SITimLayden Why have a poll if you totally ignore it? Serena FAILED at winning the Grand Slam. AP once in a lifetime horse — Justin Zayat (@JustinZayat) December 14, 2015
YES! LOOOOOOOVE. @serenawilliams that @SInow cover is EVERYTHING. #SportspersonOfTheYear #WhoRunsTheWorld
— kerry washington (@kerrywashington) December 14, 2015
I believe that It's insulting to compare a black woman to a horse in the first place. But that's just me though. #SportspersonOfTheYear — Deondrae Wiggins (@draewiggins) December 15, 2015
This reminds me of when Jesse Owens was made to race a horse to earn living expenses: https://t.co/XypyJCPyom. https://t.co/1L2fV9dAYR
— stacia l. brown (@slb79) December 14, 2015
If you're honestly mad that a horse didn't win #SportspersonOfTheYear over Serena, plz sit in the corner & think about what you're saying. — Ally Nickert (@allymarie93) December 15, 2015
Voting for American Pharaoh as #SportspersonOfTheYear is like voting for a horse as #SportsPERSONoftheYear.
— Ian MacIntyre (@MrIanMacIntyre) December 14, 2015
"Vote for a black woman as #SportspersonOfTheYear? NO WAY! I'm voting for this animal that has no idea it's even playing a sport." — Ian MacIntyre (@MrIanMacIntyre) December 14, 2015
White privelege is voting for a horse to win #SportsPERSONofTheYear and then having temper tantrums when an actual Black athlete wins.
— E Ru the Damaja (@AlluringShrew) December 14, 2015
American Pharaoh did great in 2015, but he doesn't even know what an award is and no one looks up to him. #SportsPersonOfTheYear — Franklyn François (@franklynforeal) December 14, 2015
© 2025 MusicTimes.com All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.